405 Saraland Blvd S, Unit D · Saraland, AL 36571 Call 251-422-4423
Travis Johns Law. Saraland · Mobile County, Alabama

Home / Personal Injury / The First Settlement Offer

Should I accept the first settlement offer?.

An adjuster calls with an offer and a check ready to go. It is tempting, especially with bills piling up. Before you say yes, understand what you are giving up.

A release is final

To get paid, you will sign a release. It ends your claim for good, including any injury that turns out to be worse than you thought. If you need surgery six months later, the release still stands. That is why early offers often come before anyone knows the full extent of the injury.

Why first offers are often low

Insurers make early offers to close files before injured people get advice or finish treatment. The first number is usually a starting point for negotiation. It is rarely the most the insurer will pay.

Do not cash a check from the other side’s insurer until you know what it settles. Cashing it may count as accepting the offer.

What to check before accepting any offer

  • Whether your treatment is finished, or your doctors can say what you will need in the future
  • Whether the offer covers what you will owe back from it, such as health insurance, Medicare or Medicaid reimbursement and hospital liens
  • Whether your own underinsured motorist coverage applies; if it does, your insurer must be notified in writing before you accept
  • Whether anyone else shares responsibility, such as an employer or a trucking company

How negotiation works

A typical claim is resolved after a written demand that lays out the injuries, the treatment and the evidence of fault. The insurer responds, and the two sides negotiate. If the insurer will not be reasonable, the next step is filing suit. Many cases still settle after that point.

The deadline keeps running

Talking with an adjuster does not stop the clock. Most Alabama injury claims must be filed within two years. An insurer can drag out negotiations past that date, and then the claim is gone.

Frequently asked questions

Can I reopen my claim after I settle?

Generally, no. The release ends the claim, even if your injuries turn out to be worse than you expected.

Will the insurer withdraw the offer if I get a lawyer?

Insurers expect represented people to negotiate. Getting advice usually changes the conversation, not whether a settlement is possible.

Do I have to pay my health insurer back from the settlement?

Often, yes. Health plans, Medicare and Medicaid usually have rights to be repaid, and the amount can sometimes be negotiated down.

Got an offer on the table?

The consultation is free and the advice is straight. The sooner the investigation starts, the stronger your case.